top of page

The Grocery Market is Splitting, But Independent Grocers Don't Have to Choose Sides

The grocery industry is entering a period of strategic bifurcation. Instead of competing in the middle, retailers are increasingly finding success at one of two ends of the spectrum.


On one side are value-driven grocers, focused on price, efficiency, and simplicity. On the other are fresh-format grocers, emphasizing quality, experience, and differentiation. Research from AlixPartners shows that shoppers are becoming less satisfied with “middle-of-the-road” grocery offerings and are gravitating toward retailers that clearly deliver value in one of these two ways.


This shift isn’t about one approach being better than the other. It’s about clarity. Stores that clearly deliver on what customers care about most tend to perform better than those trying to be everything at once.

Why Shoppers are Driving this Split

Even as inflation eases, grocery prices remain high enough that many shoppers are still very price conscious. According to the 2025 Grocery Shopper Perspectives Report, more than 75% of consumers have changed how they shop for groceries in the last year, and many expect those changes to continue.


At the same time, price isn’t the only factor influencing where people shop. Some shoppers are intentionally choosing stores that offer better fresh food, easier meal solutions, and a more pleasant shopping experience. These customers may visit fewer stores overall, but they’re often more loyal to the ones that feel worth the trip.


That’s where bifurcation comes in. Shoppers are increasingly choosing either:

  • Value-focused grocers, where low prices and efficiency come first

  • Fresh-format grocers, where quality, assortment, and experience matter most

Stores that fall somewhere in between can struggle to stand out, simply because customers aren’t always sure what they’re getting.

Where Independent Grocers Often Shine

As the grocery market splits between value-driven formats and fresh-focused formats, independent grocers are often better positioned than they realize. Research consistently shows that shoppers associate independent stores with freshness, quality, and trust. Surveys from the National Grocers Association find that customers rate independents especially highly for produce, meat quality, and overall shopping experience, often above larger national chains.


Several strengths tend to show up again and again in the research:

  • Strong fresh departments, especially produce and meat, which drive repeat visits

  • Local and curated assortments that shoppers actively seek out and associate with independents

  • Flexibility and agility in adjusting assortments based on local preferences and seasonality

  • A more personal shopping experience, supported by knowledgeable staff and familiar faces

These qualities align closely with the fresh-format side of the market, where shoppers are less focused on finding the lowest possible price and more focused on value, confidence, and overall experience.


Independent grocers also benefit from their ability to respond quickly. Unlike large chains, decisions about merchandising, promotions, and product mix can be made locally. That agility allows independents to test new items, highlight emerging trends, and adapt to customer feedback in ways that feel intentional rather than one-size-fits-all.


Customer experience plays a key role here. Research shows that many shoppers prefer independent stores for in-person grocery trips because the experience feels easier, more human, and more connected to the community. In a bifurcated market, that sense of trust and familiarity becomes a powerful differentiator.


As national discounters compete on price and efficiency, independent grocers have an opportunity to lean into what they already do well. By clearly delivering freshness, quality, and a differentiated experience, they give shoppers a clear reason to choose their store.

Turning Strategic Choice into Day-to-Day Success

Choosing where your store fits in a bifurcated grocery market is an important step. What ultimately determines success is how consistently that strategy shows up in daily operations.


For fresh-focused independent grocers, execution matters. Customers notice when pricing is accurate, promotions run as expected, and inventory reflects what’s actually on the shelf. They also notice when those things don’t line up.


Operational consistency often comes down to a few key areas:

  • Pricing and promotions that stay accurate and on schedule

  • Inventory data that reflects real availability

  • POS and digital systems that stay aligned

  • Online listings that match the in-store experience

Most independent grocers already have the right tools in place. Over time, though, systems can drift as assortments change, promotions evolve, and teams turn over. Small gaps can appear between the POS, inventory, and digital channels, usually without anyone realizing it.


This is where ongoing support quietly adds value. Regular system reviews, configuration adjustments, and inventory cleanup help keep everything working together as intended. The goal is not to add complexity, but to ensure the systems you rely on continue to support your strategy as your store evolves.


In a market where clarity matters, operational consistency becomes a competitive advantage. Independent grocers who back their strategic choices with clean data, connected systems, and steady support are better positioned to deliver an experience customers trust and return to.

Comments

bottom of page